Saturday, May 3, 2008

Life can be simpler!

by Gururaja Budhya


I never thought life would be so difficult. Difficulties arise due to the rigid procedures and complicated systems. If it is anything to do with the ADB, one can assume that simple can be complex – whether it is accountability and transparency. I was not sure to get my visa to Spain to attend the ADB-AGM till the last minute. Irrespective of years of experience in organizing AGMs, the ADB cannot foresee this (or may be they are aware, but do not want to address). Willy could not make it to Madrid precisely for the bureaucratic way the 'visa procedures' ask for bundles of documents, follow a rigid procedure to apply and wait. Is it the ADB way to restrict the 'participation' in AGMs?

I wonder why one has to come all the way from their countries to Madrid to meet the 'decision-makers' and the 'officials' of the bank? I do agree with Avilash when he says that money is burnt in air travel that also produces green house gases. But the point is can't the ADB develop a national annual procedure that gives the citizens more opportunity within the country to interact with the ADB resident missions, the Executive Directors and the Governor?

Thinking all these, it was the afternoon of May day that I reached Madrid. It was exhaustive travel from Bangalore – Frankfurt – Madrid that I slept the rest of the day without having the dinner. I missed the May Day celebrations of the Madrid.

2nd of May some of got early to the AGM venue, which we had to take metro and reach the IFEMA (the convention center). Registration, the materials, the coupons, the bags – it took a long time for us to find the place. The ADB is known to organize AGMs in places where it is difficult for people to reach – first the countries and then the locations within the countries.

Then we moved on to the solidarity evening with friends across the globe at Paraiso del Jamon at Noviciado, it was amazing to see the pork museum in the hotel (port hung all over the restaurant). It was a few mugs of beer, mushroom fry, potato+egg cakes with the bread that relaxed the evening. Paulina the sweet colleague was ensuring that all of us were attended. I enjoyed the atmosphere and relaxed.

Not to forget to mention the experience of metro. Deep feet below under layers of tracks that one has to constantly look for blue, pink, … lanes and keep looking at map for not missing the way. It's an experience of Madrid.

I keep coming back to the question of why the high officials are comfortable to meet or hear the CSOs or the lobbyists only in AGMs or only in their headquarters and not in the field where they implement the projects! The huge empty buildings that the ADB creates, hosts the bureaucracy that runs the show – is also empty of not knowing what and how to do? But then comes up another question – Whether the life is simpler?

2 comments:

soblue said...
This comment has been removed by the author.
soblue said...

Hi my gender-sensitive guru….

Glad to know that you arrive safely in Madrid, even you’ve contributed to climate change as stated by Avilash. :D

Thinking about Madrid, my mind was retreated to my experience last year when I was in Madrid for student-exchange program in the Universidad Fransisco de Vittoria. At that time, we have a case study about Warner Bros Amusement Park. It is a theme park located 25 km southeast of Madrid, Spain, in the municipality of San Martín de la Vega. The park opened on April 5, 2002. During its reconstruction, the park had very controversial problems such as resettlement, location which is on the top of dangerous gas-piped line, and of course related to conflict on the commodification of local traditions. The park was endangered indigenous people nearby. So many protests against the reconstruction, but the park is now there, with the entrance fee around Eur26 to Eur33 per person. Hmmm… globalization that hits culture and society, none can stop it.

So many questions came up in my mind at that time. Is it the way globalization works just like what Stiglitz critized on his book? Is Warner Brothers a free agent to impose their modes of operation on passively accepting local concerns? Then is it the meaning of what Gidden’s said about globalizations alters old forms of action and constitutes new forms of identity? But shouldn’t we all remain indissolubly linked to both the local and the global? Still… those questions didn’t stop the quarrel between residents and the corporate.

I know this is not related to AGM of ADB in Madrid, but actually my concern is the same as yours, why should hundreds people go to Madrid to think betterment in Asian economic outlook while actually the bank will still promote the major involvement of private sectors which so called as the agent of poverty eradication.

Good luck my inspiring colleague!

Hoping that my quote that I stated to my another inspiring friend this morning will give you more insight in fighting against injustice “Only people who have will who can make their wishes come true”